BSP vs PCCP Header

What Is the Difference Between PCCP and Bar-Wrapped Pipe? Similar Appearance, Different Technology

Understanding why two concrete pressure pipe systems that look similar use fundamentally different reinforcement mechanisms.

Short answer
Prestressed concrete cylinder pipe (PCCP and bar-wrapped pipe (BWP) are both concrete cylinder pressure pipes, but they use different reinforcement. PCCP (AWWA C301) uses high-strength prestressing wire to place the concrete core in compression, while BWP (AWWA C303) uses mild steel bar wrapped around a steel cylinder. These differences affect how each pipe is designed, inspected, and evaluated.

Prestressed concrete cylinder pipe (PCCP) and bar-wrapped concrete cylinder pipe (BWP) have been used in North American water infrastructure for more than 80 years. Both combine steel and cementitious materials, and both have established histories in water transmission and distribution systems.

PCCP and bar-wrapped pipe are often grouped together, but they use different reinforcement systems: PCCP uses high-strength prestressing wire, while BWP uses mild steel bar wrapped around a steel cylinder. Evaluating each on its own design and performance data gives a more accurate comparison for both existing and new pipelines.

Understanding how these two pipe systems are constructed and how they resist loads helps engineers and utility owners make informed decisions based on each product’s actual characteristics.

PCCP vs. BWP: Key Differences

PCCPBWP
AWWA standardC301 (design per C304)C303 (design per M9)
First used in the U.S.19421942
ReinforcementHigh-strength steel prestressing wireMild steel reinforcing bar
Reinforcement methodWire wrapped under high tensionBar wrapped under moderate tension
Structural mechanismPrestressed composite: concrete core, steel cylinder, and prestressing wire work togetherNon-prestressed composite: steel cylinder, reinforcing bar, and cement mortar work together
Behaves likeRigid pipeSemi-rigid pipe
Condition assessment focusPrestressing-wire condition (e.g., electromagnetic inspection and acoustic monitoring)Steel cylinder, reinforcing bar, and mortar coating condition
Bar wrapped concrete cylinder pipe cross-sectional with joint detail.
Bar-wrapped concrete cylinder pipe (AWWA C303): joint detail
Bar wrapped concrete cylinder pipe wall cutaway.
Bar-wrapped concrete cylinder pipe (AWWA C303): wall cutaway
Prestressed concrete embedded cylinder pipe cross-sectional with joint detail.
Prestressed concrete embedded cylinder pipe (E-301): joint detail
Prestressed concrete embedded cylinder pipe (E-301) wall cutaway
Prestressed concrete embedded cylinder pipe (E-301): wall cutaway
Prestressed concrete lined cylinder pipe (L-301) cross-sectional with joint detail
Prestressed concrete lined cylinder pipe (L-301): joint detail
Prestressed concrete lined cylinder pipe (L-301) wall cutaway
Prestressed concrete lined cylinder pipe (L-301): wall cutaway

Two Proven Technologies. One Engineering Resource.
At Thompson Pipe Group, we manufacture both prestressed concrete cylinder pipe and bar-wrapped concrete cylinder pipe, allowing us to support projects with different structural, hydraulic, and installation requirements.

Related Reading:

How Has PCCP Evolved Since the 1970s?
Resources – Thompson Pipe Group
Prestressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe (AWWA C301)
Bar-Wrapped Concrete Cylinder Pipe (AWWA C303)

References

American Concrete Pressure Pipe Association (ACPPA) What Is Concrete Pressure Pipe (CPP) | ACPPA
American Water Works Association. AWWA C301-14(R19): Prestressed Concrete Pressure Pipe, Steel-Cylinder Type
American Water Works Association. AWWA C303-24: Concrete Pressure Pipe, Bar-Wrapped Steel-Cylinder Type
American Water Works Association. AWWA C304-14: Design of Prestressed Concrete Cylinder Pipe

American Water Works Association. Manual of Water Supply Practices M9: Concrete Pressure Pipe, Third Edition.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Name

Read More

→
What Is the Difference Between PCCP and Bar-Wrapped Pipe? Similar Appearance, Different Technology Product Insights

What Is the Difference Between PCCP and Bar-Wrapped Pipe? Similar Appearance, Different Technology

Understanding why two concrete pressure pipe systems that look similar...
Read More
Improvements in AWWA C301 standard since the 1970’s Product Insights

Improvements in AWWA C301 standard since the 1970’s

Few pipe materials in the pressure pipe market have a...
Read More
Thompson Pipe Group logo featuring a droplet-shaped icon in blue and brown alongside bold text.

The widest range of precast, pressure, and trenchless pipe solutions in North America, backed by industry-leading engineering and logistics. Thompson Pipe Group delivers all that.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.

At Your Service.

Complete the form below so we can connect you with the right person to help. We typically respond within a day. If your request is urgent, please don’t wait—find all our contact details by state under Contacts.